By julianne on
Jan. 22, 2014
Forums:
Hi
Does anybody here use chineese embroidery machines? I've got two multihead Tajima but need more productivity and don't have a lot of money to spend for another Tajima. Is the quality of chineese brands better than it used to be few years ago?
Location:
United States
Re: Richpeace, Feyia, Richrui and other chineese brands
Hi Julianne,
I have worked with Ricoma and Richrui Single head in the last two years. Yes they have improved since the early years but they are not even close to Tajima and Barudan. Biggest Problem is the tensioning. The use of cheap material and missing precision in production result in an inconsistent tension. So you will have to adjust the tension more often than on a Tajima. And you will still have more thread breaks than on other machines. But it isn't as bad as it sounds right now. After you have figured out how to run the machine best, you can produce nice embroidery for a cheap price. I would recommend to change the tension springs, this helps a lot....
If you go with Chinese machines you should choose a big one. A 6 or 8 head directly from china costs 10-15k plus shipping. And you will need a big one because you have to run this machines a lot slower than Japanese. With 650-750 St/min on flat and 550-650 St/min on caps I would suggest. Richrui is not producing for them self. Zhuji Fuwei is producing for them and labeling it richrui.
http://zjfuwei.en.alibaba.com/
You might get a good deal from them.
Re: Richpeace, Feyia, Richrui and other chineese brands
Ok, and how about this Richpeace brand? They look a little bit more professional...
Re: Richpeace, Feyia, Richrui and other chineese brands
I haven’t worked with them yet. But the differents between the Chinese machines are very small. They all use the same parts. None of them are producing pressure foots, needle bars, rotary hooks or the electronics. All of them are buying the parts somewhere else and just build the together. It is a little bit like building a house. You get the furniture from company A, the electronics from B and the Windows from Company C. The embroidery Computers come from Dahao or Topwisdom, the main embroidery machine parts (pressure foot, needle bar...) from another company and some parts are usually imported (rotary hook, belt....).
Maybe you should go to trade show or exhibition. Normally there are some Chinese manufacturers presenting their product. If you are early you can buy on of their machines from the show. You can save the shipping costs to the USA and they can save the shipping costs back to china. And you know that the machine is running smoothly, because they only take the best built machines to the show.
Re: Richpeace, Feyia, Richrui and other chineese brands
Does a cheap machine that is not nearly as producitve really save you money or does it end up costing you more ?
My biggest cost is payroll so I want my payroll expenses to go as far as possible which means I want to be running the most productive machines that I can run.
One of my operators makes more in a week than the machine cost in a months lease payment so do I really want slow the employee down ?
Service expenses on china equipment will be higher and getting parts may often be an issue as well which leads to more down time. China machines also will not hold their value well so that should be factored into your investment.
The Quality of the embroidery is not nearly as good because the machines are not as precise so the embroidery quality suffers.
You may think your saving money on the purchase but I really question if that up front savings is a real savings over time.
Re: Richpeace, Feyia, Richrui and other chineese brands
Price for 8-head Richpeace or Feiya in my region(Europe) is 1/4 of a new 8-head Tajima. I'm able to have 2x8 china heads for half price of 8-head Tajima. Tajima goes with speed around 900, china - 700.
I still have my Tajimas to do high quality production, and look for something cheap to embroider easy designs.
The most interesting question for me is what happens if I run the same .dst file in a tajima and china machine. Is it only the speed difference or the quality will be poor when I compare the results?
Re: Richpeace, Feyia, Richrui and other chineese brands
LogoAdvantage has a point with the payroll. That was the main reason why we sold our two single head from china. We are a small company and it is important for us that the machine can run a big design unattended, while we continue working on other projects like preparing a screen for screen printing. But if you have two multiheads you will have always one or two people hooping and working in front of the machine. The differents is: with a tajima you need one man for hooping and operating for china machines maybe two. So that one is always hooping and one is helping to hoop or fixing thread breaks. In my opinion it is better to have less personal and a better machine running flawless. But if you have already enough manpower and they still have time after hooping for the tajima the Chinese machines can work.
Service and spare parts should be no problem. Every Tech from Happy, Barudan or Tajima can fix a Richpeace or Feyia. And for spare parts you can ask any distributor of chinese machines in your country (Ricoma, CTC, Richpeace) they all have the same parts. Or you are using Fedex express and it will be there in 2-3 days. And you will always receive a box full of spare parts with the machine.
If I put an embroidery from my Barudan next to a china machine I can see the different quality. But it is not that big and you have to see them next to each other to recognize it. Small lettering and some cap designs can be problematic.
For sure you have a reseller of Ricoma in your country. Send them a file that you have done with your tajima and compare it later on. You have to decide if the quality is good enough for you.
Re: Richpeace, Feyia, Richrui and other chineese brands
What is the main reason for thread breaks? Replacing rotary hooks and tension springs + setting hook timing solves the problem? Or maybe these machines are so badly produced that nothing helps to make them working fine for a longer time.
Re: Richpeace, Feyia, Richrui and other chineese brands
You can improve the machine by using good springs. This is what the distributors of Ricoma and KSM are doing in Germany. The Results are better but it is still not the same like Tajima. The people assembling these machines in china are no engineers and they are working with very simple tools. If they drill a hole a few mm left or right from the correct spot or if a bearing is sitting to tight or lose it will influence the performance of the machine. Lower quality plastic and metal materials used for the parts will have an influence too. The machine will function correctly but any mistake will have an effect on the tension. I have seen machines running for several hours without breaks and I have seen machines where you had thread breaks every 20-30.000 Stitches...
You might consider buying a machine from good distributor in your Country. If he knows what he is doing he has tested the machine for one or two days before selling it. In Germany you could go to our Barudan distributor because they are selling machines from China (CTC-Brand) too. And you can expect a good service and people who know what they doing. But the price will be a totally different one than in china.
Re: Richpeace, Feyia, Richrui and other chineese brands
quotes like "quality not even close", "more thread breaks", "run machines slower" and "change the springs" would make me RUN away from those machines,, not even consider them! What about a pre-owned Tajima? you already have them, so you already know what they can do... nothing new to learn. Are your current machines running 24/7? three shifts plus weekends? if not then there is an opportunity without buying a machine until they are running as much as possible?
Thread breaks.... to me the quality of the thread is the main issue... then needles, then operator ability to have proper tensions. Similar question.... do you go cheaper and spend more in TIME? (Tajima vs lesser, or quality thread vs not so much). Pay up front and enjoy years of quality without second guessing yourself.
Modern Embroidery Designer
volant-tech.com
volantfineart.com
Re: Richpeace, Feyia, Richrui and other chineese brands
Robert, this is not USA(unfortunately). Tajima is popular but pre-owned market doesn't exist. Only few pieces, really old. Buying used machines from Tajima rep. doesn't make sense, price is close to a new one(reason above)
This topic is not for economical advices because we live in different economical conditions.
I just want to know how does the newest generation of china machines work in production. Thank to pd87 I know that Richrui is not for me. Feyia looks very "garage". And how about Richpeace? Anybody who knows models that are now in their offer?
Re: Richpeace, Feyia, Richrui and other chineese brands
ah, sorry about that, very few tend to put WHERE they are, so it can be hard to provide regional experiences that make sense. I have experienced Richpeace a couple of years ago and it was not pretty for the client that owned them... now maybe they have improved a lot in 2 years, but I tend to bet probably not. sorry. Still think your answer is a resounding NOOOO... lol use the current machines as many hours a week as possible and then buy a new Tajima if is is nearly the same as a preowned one.
Modern Embroidery Designer
volant-tech.com
volantfineart.com
Re: Richpeace, Feyia, Richrui and other chineese brands
Why was he unsatisfied with Richpeace? Because of speed, thread breaks or something else? I'm not new in embroidery and I know general opinion about china stuff. I'd like to collect more precise, technical and up-to-date information about each brand from real users.
Re: Richpeace, Feyia, Richrui and other chineese brands
Why ask for an opinion when you clearly are fishing for the "right" answer? The chinese don't engineer embroidery machines, the Japanese did it for them. They then took them apart and copied them. A simple spring or machined part is constructed from an engineer's standpoint with careful application of temper or heat treating. Chinese engineering? Hey that looks close. It might run but in the long run it most likely won't last becoming a very nice piece of industrial scrap metal.
I can't offer you any precise information about a particular machine because it's not worth my hard earned money to spend it on questionable equipment. It's ultimately up to you but why do you want to waste time and money on equipment that uses different hoops, fixtures and methods when in the long run sticking with similar machines would net you more of a gain?
Re: Richpeace, Feyia, Richrui and other chineese brands
Thank you Robert, that article is really helpful. No, I didn't make any decission. As I said before, I work in much harder conditions comparing to Usa. Japan machines cost 30% more than for american market and the pricing for embroidery is maybe 50% of what you guys take from your clients. Only the payroll is a little smaller. My Tajimas do their quality work and nothing will change with it. At this point I'm only considering a new cheap multihead machine to do easy designs and give me some extra money. Taking tajima to do this job kills the profit at least for 5 years(typical lease time).
Re: Richpeace, Feyia, Richrui and other chineese brands
Good machines are always cheaper than people in the long run. From a 19 year Barudan house.
Re: Richpeace, Feyia, Richrui and other chineese brands
maybe this link will help? http://www.ajstitch.com/index.php/ajst-faqs/embroidery-machine-faqs/151-neo-chinese-and-chinese-embroidery-machines
but it kinda sounds like you are just looking for a positive review to justify a decision you have already made?
Modern Embroidery Designer
volant-tech.com
volantfineart.com
Re: Richpeace, Feyia, Richrui and other chineese brands
Julianne, so what part of the world are you in? 30 percent increase in price of machine yet half of ability to charge and only a little reduction in payroll to me would mean finding a "niche" that you could charge more for and become a "specialist" in.... several of my clients have done this... and after a few years in a particular "niche" they are working less but earning more. maybe this is the answer to your problem? so you can earn more with the machines you have and Not buy any more for now?
Modern Embroidery Designer
volant-tech.com
volantfineart.com
Re: Richpeace, Feyia, Richrui and other chineese brands
I run my business in Czech Republic, Europe. Generally I do custom embroidery but people here are still not able to pay as much as they should for high quality work. Low price is the most important factor. I see that china machines are becoming very popular so I'm a little afraid that in short time I will have to fight with prices even lower than now.
Re: Richpeace, Feyia, Richrui and other chineese brands
Julianne, There is always going to be customers looking for cheap, just like there are always customers that are more concerned about quality and service.
We fight that in the USA as well but maybe with different variables.
Buying cheap machines is not always a real savings and I think that is what many people here are trying to caution you about. The savings up front could end up costing you more in the long run and it will surely effect the efficiency of your production as well as the quality of the work you produce.
Personally I would never want to save money on a machine and that savings simply end up causing me headaches and more cost in the long run.
Move forward with caution. It seems that many people here are trying to give you a word of caution and I personally think they are giving you good advice.
Re: Richpeace, Feyia, Richrui and other chineese brands
I work on a lot of the Chinese machines and the main issue with most of them is quality control. You can get two identical machines off the same shipment and one may sew like a champ. The other may never sew a lick.
Ricoma, Pantograms, and Datastitch, are turning out a new single head machine that is head over hills better than the Chinese norm that we are all familiar with and that generate most of the negative views in the forums. These new machines, I unofficially named them Neo-Chinese machines, have better components, better electric boards, and are put together with better quality control than the normal Chinese machines. These new machines are still not as good as a Tajima, Barudan, or ZSK but they are half the price.
If you do decide to buy a multi-head Chinese machine I would strongly encourage you to buy from a distributor in the states. Most of the Distributors that I have worked with are very willing to work with you when you have an issue with your machine, they speak American most of the time, and they honor their warranties. Changing out the tension springs and knobs does help with the tension issues.
The time difference, distance, and language barriers work against you when you buy direct from overseas. Email correspondence takes about 24 hours, components and parts takes about 3 weeks to ship from overseas, and a overseas phone call to a person that may or may not speak engliss is expensive.
Re-sale value is another consideration. Do a Google search for used machines and compare a 10 year old Tajima verses a 10 year old Feiya. On the other hand, these used Chinese machines do make fantastic boat anchors.
Dennis Wilson
Embroidery Machine Technician
ajstitch.com Dennis@ajstitch.com
Re: Richpeace, Feyia, Richrui and other chineese brands
I read over the part where you are not in the states. I would assume that most of what I wrote would apply to where you live, specifically the part where I suggest buy from a local distributor if available.
Good luck.
Dennis Wilson
Embroidery Machine Technician
ajstitch.com Dennis@ajstitch.com
Re: Richpeace, Feyia, Richrui and other chineese brands
Richpeace is the producer for their electronics.
If you are lucky can have an good machine.
My advice:
Second hand Tajima